Homes For Sale In Sunset Hill

Homes For Sale In Sunset Hill

About Sunset Hill

If you’re looking for the best place to view the sunset on Staten Island, look no further than the neighborhood of Sunset Hill. This area is actually a subset of the larger neighborhood of West Brighton. It is just south of Forest Avenue and bordered by Clove Lakes Park on the west and Silver Lake on the east. Residents can easily handle everyday errands while also enjoying their free time.

History of Sunset Hill

Factoryville

Once farmland, the area became booming with factories and businesses in the 1800s, and was named Factoryville by textile entrepreneur Nathan Barrett. He founded Barrett, Tileston & Co., the island’s first industrial business, which specialized in textile dyeing, printing, and fabric cleaning. Local entrepreneurs started to build European-style homes near their businesses out of convenience. Many of these elegant homes, including Victorian and Greek Revival styles, still stand today

Dorothy Valentine Smith House

Sunset Hill continued to be home to affluent families throughout the 19th century. One home is the Dorothy Valentine Smith house, located at 1213 Cloved Road, which became a historic landmark in 1987. She was a founding member of the Richmondtown Restoration. The house was built by her father, John Frederick Smith, who was a prominent Staten Island banker. Its Queen Anne style includes elements such as a wraparound porch and a tall chimney.

Gardiner-Tyler House

The Greek Revival home at 27 Tyler Street, built in 1835, was the residence of Julia Gardiner Tyler, who married President John Tyler in 1844. This historic house showcases classic Greek Revival architecture with beautiful columns and a symmetrical design. Julia Gardiner Tyler, known for her role as First Lady, added historical significance to the property, which remains an important example of early 19th-century architecture in Sunset Hill.

Sunset Hill Homes for Sale

There are many charming, historic homes in Sunset Hill. It remains home to some of West Brighton’s more affluent residents, including politicians, lawyers, judges, and other professionals, particularly east of Broadway. 

Most of the homes for sale in Sunset Hill are single-family houses, but you can also find some multi-family properties. These bigger homes are great for buyers who want to rent out parts of their property and earn some extra income. Sunset Hill is very well-maintained and holds its value over time. Residents will be happy to live in this area due to its beautiful homes and scenery. There are many activities to explore associated with the local parks.

Sunset Hill Entertainment & Amenities

Staten Island Zoo

The Staten Island Zoo is a popular spot for animal lovers, featuring a wide range of animals and one of North America’s largest rattlesnake collections. This zoo opened in 1936 and highlights include diverse habitats, a Children’s Center with interactive exhibits, and the famous Groundhog Day event with Staten Island Chuck. Residents in the Northeast look forward to seeing if Chuck sees his shadow or not and finding out if spring is in sight. The zoo also offers educational programs and seasonal events, making it a vibrant community hub.

Cloves Lakes Park

Residents and visitors can enjoy a day out at Clove Lakes park. It has beautiful walking trails, a serene lake for paddle boating, and lots of picnic areas. You’ll find joggers and dog walkers enjoying the scenic paths and lush greenery. The park has some of the island’s oldest trees. You can even ice skate on the lake in winter. The sports fields and playgrounds are a family-friendly place to relax and enjoy nature.

Silver Lake Park

Silver Lake Park is a great spot on Staten Island for a relaxing day outdoors. The park features a popular golf course, tennis courts, and a large lake with scenic walking paths. There are also playgrounds for kids, picnic areas, and beautiful flower displays in spring and summer. 

The Staten Island Cricket Club

Founded in 1872, this club is one of the oldest cricket clubs in the United States. Members represent all parts of the world, including the United States, India, Pakistan, Trinidad, Jamaica, Ireland, England, Sri Lanka, and South Africa. It boasts dedicated facilities for both recreational and competitive cricket, hosting a range of matches and events throughout the year. With its long-standing legacy, the Staten Island Cricket Club is a key part of local sports culture.

Restaurants in Sunset Hill

Staten Islanders flock to Sunset Hill and nearby areas to eat at Duffy’s, which is known for its burgers, Panini Grill, which serves delicious sandwiches, pizza, and more, and Burrito Bar, which is a Mexican restaurant with a fun atmosphere. The Kings Arms Diner is a cozy spot where the locals love to go for breakfast and lunch. Jody’s Club Forest is a popular spot for casual dining and socializing. It offers a range of American comfort foods and often hosts live music and themed events.

Sunset Hill Schools

Many children in Sunset Hill attend P.S. 45, the John Tyler school, which is a public elementary school and I.S. 27, Anning S. Prall Intermediate School, which is a public intermediate school. These New York City Department of Education schools are known for their strong academic programs and welcoming atmospheres that support diverse student bodies. 

Sunset Hill FAQ

Q: What makes Sunset Hill a great place to live?

A: Sunset Hill is known for its beautiful views during sunset. The neighborhood offers a blend of historic charm and modern amenities, with well-maintained homes and a strong sense of community. It has easy access to nearby parks, Clove Lakes and Silver Lake.

Q: What famous landmarks are in Sunset Hill, Staten Island?

A: In Sunset Hill, there’s a mix of historic and modern homes. Many properties are single-family houses, with some featuring charming, older architecture. There are also multi-family homes available for those looking for rental income opportunities or more space.

Q: What is the transportation like in Sunset Hill?

A: Sunset Hill is accessible through local bus routes. Residents can connect to the Staten Island Railway for easy travel throughout the island. Major roadways like the Staten Island Expressway are also nearby.